|
|
| |
|
|
Authentic Magisterium of the Catholic
Church |
CHAPTER I, part 2
THE MAGISTERIUM OF THE CHURCH AND RELATED ISSUES
THE INFALLIBILITY OF THE MAGISTERIUM
As noted in Chapter I, the Church, by God's will,
is a hierarchical institution. At its 'head' is the Pope,
the vicar of Christ, the 'rock' on which the Church is founded.
He is endowed with all the unique authority of Jesus Christ 'who is
the shepherd and bishop of our souls' (1 Pet. 2:25), and
depending upon Him, the pope is also - but vicariously - the shepherd and bishop
of the whole flock, both of the other bishops and of the ordinary faithful (John
21:15-17) He is the evident and effectual sign of the presence of Christ in
the world, and it is through him that Christ who is invisible in the bosom of
the Father, visibly presides over all the activities of this enormous Body and
brings it under His control. As Dom Grea has said, 'the pope is with
Jesus Christ - a single hierarchical person - above the episcopate, one and
the same head of the episcopate, one and the same head, one and the same doctor,
pontiff and legislator of the universal Church.' Or more precisely,
'Jesus Christ Himself is the sole Head, rendered visible, speaking
and acting in the Church through the instrument whom He provided for Himself.
Christ proclaims Himself through His Vicar, He speaks through him, acts and
governs through him.' When Christ speaks, acts, and governs through
the pope, the pope is endowed with infallibility, a quality which derives, not
from him as a private person, but from his being 'a single hierarchical
person' with Christ.
This conception is made clear by Pope St. Leo's
third sermon on the anniversary of his own election where he paraphrases the
words of Christ: 'I make known to thee thy excellence, for thou art
Peter: that is, as I am the invulnerable rock, the cornerstone, who make both
one, I the foundation beside which there can be laid no other; so thou too art
a rock, in my strength made hard, and I share with thee the powers which are
proper to me. And upon this rock I will build my Church and the gates of hell
shall not prevail against it...' (Office of St. Peter's Chair
at Antioch, Feb. 22.)
The pope is also a private person (an ordinary
human being) and a private theologian (doctor). It is however, only when he
functions as 'a single hierarchical person' with Christ that
he is endowed with infallibility (or partakes of the Church's, i.e., Christ's
infallibility.) It is only then that Christ's Scriptural statement 'he
who hears you, hears me' applies. And it follows logically that his
authority is extended through those bishops who 'are in union with
him' in governing the flock. The bishops have no independent authority
apart from him for the simple reason that he has no independent authority apart
from Christ. Thus it is that he is called the 'Bishop of bishops',
and that he 'confirms' them in their doctrine - not the other
way around. Thus it is that no statement of an Ecumenical Council has any authority
until it receives his approbation.
The pope then has an almost limitless authority.
He can however loose this authority in a variety of ways. He can lose it when
he dies (physical death), if he loses his reason (madness), if he separates
himself from the Church (schism), or when he loses his faith (heresy and therefore
spiritual death). At such a point the pope is no longer pope because it is the
very nature of this bishop's function and ministry to be the Vicar of Christ
and nothing else.
The pope's authority is almost unlimited - however,
it is not absolute. He has full powers within his charge, but his powers are
limited by his charge. In order fully to understand this doctrinal point, let
us once again recall the nature of this charge.
The ecclesiastical hierarchy was instituted by
God to teach, that is to say, to transmit the deposit of the faith. At the head
of this teaching Church Christ appointed a Vicar to whom He gave full powers
to 'feed the faithful and the shepherds' (John 21:11-17).
Consequently, it is within the bounds of this function, the transmission of
the deposit of the faith, that the Pope has 'full powers'.
He has these precisely to enable him to transmit the deposit of the faith -
in its entirety - 'in the same meaning and the same sense'
(Denzinger 1800). 'For', as Vatican I clearly taught,
'the Holy Spirit has not been promised to Peter's successors in order
that they might reveal, under His inspiration, new doctrine, but in order that,
with His help, they may carefully guard and faithfully expound the revelation
as it was handed down by the Apostles, that is to say, the deposit of the faith'
(Pastor Aeternus, Ds. 1836).
Hence it follows that the Pope can and must make
all his determinations entirely within the bounds of orthodoxy, and this is
true whether they concern the reformation of the Liturgy, of Canon Law, or to
use the phraseology of earlier Councils, the reformation of the clergy 'in
its head or in its members.' The Pope may indeed abrogate all the
decisions of his predecessors, even those deserving of special mention, but
always and only within the limits of orthodoxy. As The Catholic Encyclopedia
(1908) states: 'the scope of this infallibility is to preserve the
deposit of faith revealed to man by Christ and His Apostles.' It goes
without saying that under such circumstances, any changes introduced would affect
only matters that are mutable and never the faith itself. A Pope who presumed
to abrogate the smallest iota of dogma, or even attempted to change the meaning
of the Church's constant teaching, would step outside the bounds of orthodoxy
and outside the limits of his function of preserving the deposit of the faith.
He would in doing so, teach a new doctrine and a 'new gospel',
and as such would be subject to the anathema pronounced by St. Paul in his Epistle
to the Galatians (1:8-9).
It is then clear that the infallibility of the Magisterium or
'teaching authority of the Church' derives from the Pope functioning
as one hierarchical person with Christ. Thus the source of this infallibility
is Christ, and indeed, it could be not be otherwise. For the Church to claim
infallibility on any other grounds would be absurd. And just as there is only
one source, so also there is only one Magisterium. When the Pope uses his infallibility
- be it by solemn proclamation or within the bounds of the ordinary magisterium,
he partakes, not of some personal, but of Christ's infallibility. As the official
text puts it, 'when he speaks ex cathedra...
he has the same infallibility as that with which the divine Redeemer invested
His Church when it is defining a doctrine concerning faith or morals; and that
therefore, such definitions of the Roman Pontiff are of themselves, and not
from the consent of the Church, irreformable'. (Ds. 1839)
FOOTNOTES
PODSUMOWANIE (A SUMMARY):
infallibility - magisterium - forts dans la foi - noel barbara - pope
- lose - bishop |
|